We had some fun testing jackets. Here’s the Nimbus by Rab – a good choice for warmth, if you can live with the annoying hood.
Down is warm and light, so makes a perfect insulator for autumn and winter jackets. The big downside, though, is that it comes from ducks and geese. Fortunately, there are now puffa and padded jackets without feathers that have all the benefits as well as being better than down in wet weather.
Why not feathers and down?
The cheaper your jacket, the more likely it is that cruelty was involved in its making. Even companies that claim their down is responsibly sourced can’t ever be certain feathers haven’t been painfully plucked. In the worst cases, feathers are ripped out, leaving birds bleeding and in agony.
Some of the very best companies say they use only down that has been naturally shed. It’s gathered and the birds are left with a synthetic replacement to line their nests. You can imagine how expensive that makes a jacket.
Very few of us absolutely need the light weight of real down, and there are now plenty of alternatives that offer similar insulation, pack down small and have the advantage of being easier to clean and dry. Down is a bit rubbish when wet and can even lose its qualities in damp or sweaty conditions.
Synthetic ‘down’ – easier to care for too
The most widely used materials are Thinsulate, FullRange, PolarTec Alpha and PrimaLoft. Of these, PrimaLoft is a great, water-resistant insulator developed for the US army. It comes in three levels of performance – black, silver and gold. You’ll find it in jackets made by companies such as Montane, Vaude, Patagonia, Helly Hansen, The North Face and many more.
Our top choices for down jacket alternatives
Most manufacturers make the same jacket in a men’s and a women’s fit. We didn’t try anything costing more than £150, and tried to get a good cross-section of price and brand. We didn’t find a completely waterproof version but all models are water-resistant and they dry much faster than down. Here’s what we found, with our favourites highlighted.
Also have a look at our article on down-free sleeping bag choices.
Columbia Powder Lite for women
Columbia
Top choice: The Powder Lite jackets for men and women are quite brilliant – very warm, a lovely fit and light to wear. Plus you can choose from hooded and hoodless versions and a longer length jackets. Lots of good colourways too. Only niggle – the zip is on the wrong side! Or am I going mad?
Powder Lite for men
The lining is both breathable and keeps heat in
Inside is a reflective lining that keeps body heat in without making you sweaty. Warm-lined pockets and a drawstring in the hem. Price from around £50.
Rab
Rab jackets tend to come up a bit small in the men’s sizes, so you might need a size up if you want to layer T-shirts and jumpers underneath. Women’s can be a bit loose.
Rab Nimbus
Rab Nimbus
Rab Nebula
Rab Nebula
Top choices: The Rab Nimbus is warm, has an elasticated hood (can’t be adjusted, sadly) and heat-retaining collar, good pockets and nice touches, such as the zip guard and the soft lining inside the zip. Its outer material is quite thin, which makes it lighter, but you’ll want to be cautious around thorns and the like. Some poele find the hood annoying as it stays where it is when you move your head!
The Rab Nebula is a bulkier, technical jacket that feels very warm. It has a nicely elongated back and an adjustable hood with a peak (a bonus over the Nimbus). The women’s version felt a bit too bulky for us – OK for walking, but you’d be better with the Nimbus if you need to move your arms around a lot.
- Pertex Quantum® outer fabric (Nimbus) and Endurance® (Nebula)
- Cirrus™ by 3M Featherless insulation
- Nimbus; Around 450g (M, size L ) and around £120
- Nebula: Around 580g (M, Size L) and just under the £150 mark
The Rab Altus is more or less the Nimbus without a hood. Around £95
Rab Altus
Rab Altus
Didriksons Reed
Didriksons Rory
Didriksons
Top class construction and a price tag to match, but the Didriksons Reed jacket for men is probably our favourite for style. The fit seems true to size and, though a bit bulkier than a down jacket would be, it’s very warm and light.
- EVOdown and 100% polyamide outer
- Fixed hood with peak
- High collar
- Extra reinforcement on the shoulders and under the sleeces
- Water repellent
- Around £140
The Rory is the equivalent for women. Just as warm and well-designed, but we found the fit a bit large and weren’t too keen on the colour details on the old rust and blue versions (white zip pull?). The black is very functional, windproof and gets our thumbs-up for style, however. Around £120.
North Face
North Face Thermoball
North Face Thermoball
Only one synthetic down option from North Face, as far as we can tell. But there are a few different styles in the Thermoball™ range. They come with very lightweight insulation, making them more packable.
Because they’re thinner, they feel nice to move around in, plus we like the elongated back. If you like a square-shaped jacket that would work in town, this will suit you well. We didn’t like the ugly exposed metal zip on the women’s version, though.
- Thermoball™ lightweight insulation
- Ripstop nylon outer shell
- Hooded versions and gilets available too
- From £55 upwards
Montane Prism
Montane Prism
Montane Fireball
Montane
Some lovely looking jackets in Montane’s extensive synthetic down range and at pretty good prices too.
The Prism jacket (for men and women) and the Fireball (men only) don’t have the typical baffles of a puffa-style jacket, but it do have a layer of silver Primaloft inside to keep you warm. We liked their sleekness and the articulated arms for ease of movement, plus the long back. Water repellent too.
- Pertex Quantum® rip-stop fabric (Fireball), Microlight Mini (Prism)
- PrimaLoft® silver eco insulation for lightweight packability
- PEAQ synthetic lining
- Hood (peaked in the Prism) and pull-over versions available.
- From £70
Montane Hi-Q Luxe
Montane Hi-Q Luxe
Top choice: The Hi-Q Luxe jackets and Icarus/Phoenix (men/women) are slightly heavier and have the stitched baffles. Really stylish and the only let-down is the non-adjustable hood. Very toasty.
- Pertex Quantum® eco rip-stop fabric
- PrimaLoft® gold eco insulation (Hi-Q),PrimaLoft® ThermoPlume (Icarus/Phoenix)
- PEAQ synthetic lining
- Elasticated hood. Pull-over version available too
- Hi-Q from around £120 (cheaper for the pull-on version). Phoenix around £130 and Icarus around £125
Montane Icarus
Montane Phoenix
Montane Flux
Top choice for something a bit different: The Flux jacket uses recycled fibres and is another baffle-free design, this time heavier weight for the coldest conditions. Men only.
- Pertex Quantum® rip-stop fabric (showerproof)
- PrimaLoft® silver eco insulation
- PEAQ synthetic lining
- Adjustable hood with peak
- From around £120 (cheaper for the pull-on version)
Vaude
The shiny fabrics and rather serious cut of some of Vaude’s synthetic down jackets won’t suit everyone’s taste. Prices are good, though, and there’s nice moveability in these designs. And you’ve got to love Vaude for their eco credentials and their commitment to fair labour.
Vaude Sesvenna
Vaude Sesvenna
The Sesvenna jacket is a stretchy ski jacket that looks rather cool (and fairly warm). It has elasticated inserts, but is still water resistant. A thin and light option for those who want to wave their arms around.
- Polyester and polyamide outer fabrics
- PrimaLoft® silver eco insulation
- Hood and thumb-holes
- Weight: Around 380g to 500g depending on size
- From around £125
Vaude Bormio
Vaude Bormio
Almost a down jacket, the Bormio has the minimum Polartec insulation, but what you lose in filling, you gain in breathability, stretchiness and great form-fitting moveability. From around £110. A top choice for runners and autumn walking.
Sprayway Selen
Sprayway Rador
Sprayway
Just two jackets from Sprayway. The Selen (women) and Rador (men). Both use micro-baffles filled with lightweight synthetic down.
- Simple designs with a basic hood
- High neck
- Around 600g (men) and 400g (women)
- Both around £90.
Our tester really liked the SJ6 jacket and thought it would be both warm enough and stylish enough.
Snugpak
Snugpak uses its Softie® insulation in the jacket range. It’s the same insulation as you’ll find in their sleeping bags. It’s bulkier and heavier than some of the other down alternatives, but you gain in warmth. There are no women’s-fit versions – just smaller men’s, which means shape is a bit lacking.
Top choice: The SJ series jackets each come with a different number – 3, 6, 9 or 12 – with 12 the warmest. Our tester liked its boxy shape and slightly longer back, and found the SJ6 very toasty indeed. Zip a bit tricky at first and a basic hood, but an excellent price for a good all-round jacket. The olive green was smart enough for town use too.
- Paratex Micro outer and Paratex Light inner
- Filled with Softie® Premier insulation
- From around £80
The Snugpak Sasquatch is, indeed, a beast of a coat.
Snugpak Sasquatch
- Filled with Softie® Premier insulation
- Adjustable hood
- Warm down to -10
- Around 1050g
- Costs around £115
Patagonia Nano-Puff
Patagonia Nano-Puff
Top choice for warmth: Patagonia Hyper-Puff
Top choice for warmth: Patagonia Hyper-Puff
Patagonia
Either the Nano-Puff or Hyper-Puff, depending on your warmth v. bulk criteria. The Nano is a slim-fitting, lightweight jacket, while the Hyper is…puffier, but stretchy. Both are water-resistant.
- Recycled polyester outer (Nano). Pertex Quantum® 100% nylon stretch (Hyper)
- PrimaLoft® gold insulation (Nano). High-loft HyperDAS™ insulation (Hyper)
- Hood and hoodless versions for the Nano, plus pull-over version.
- Around 340g (Nano) and 525g (Hyper)
- From around £70
Craghoppers Ascent
Craghoppers Compresslite II
Craghoppers
For the cheapest option, Craghoppers has a Compresslite range for men and women. They’re windproof and water resistant and pretty lightweight for non-down. There’s a wide range of different styles, including gilets, jackets with hoods and more coat-like options, for both men and women. They’re not the bee’s knees on the style front, but great for affordable, packable warmth.
- Polyester outer
- ClimaPlus insulation
- From around £20
If you have a favourite synthetic insulated jacket that works well for you, do tell us a bit about it. If you really do need to have a down-filled jacket, then have a look at the welfare credentials of the company. If they stick to standards, they’ll trumpet it on their labels, but it’s worth just double-checking what the promises actually mean. Meanwhile, here’s more info on down production.
Camping gear must-haves – our 60 best finds
Read More
